Product as described

Decent for the price I paid.

Its ok

This hardware is beautiful!! We recently updated our kids bathroom and I wanted all matte black hardware to match the new faucet but I didn’t want to spend a fortune. These fit the bill. The only downside (and not really if you’re careful) is that they scratch easy while installing. I learned that while hanging the towel ring and was more careful with the other items so they were fine. Everything is very sturdy! I have 4 kids sharing this bathroom so I think that speaks volumes to the level of sturdiness and durability!

The product itself is decent quality. Looks good too, but it's not a 24" bar towel. More like 20"